McCoy Training and Development Resources
Services
Biography
MTDR Associates
Books
Managing a Small HRD DepartmentManaging a Small HRD Department
In Action: Managing the Small Training StaffManaging the Small Training Staff
Book ReviewsBook Reviews
Other BooksOther Books
Courses
Workshops
Resources
Links
ASTD
Genealogy
Email-Contact Carol McCoy
HOME
Buy this Book: Click Here Now!
Book Reviews
Buy this Book: Click Here Now!



Reviews from Professional Organizations

From Knight Ridder/Tribute News Service, January 1999
Managing a Small HRD Department: You Can Do More Than You Think by Carol P. McCoy (Jossey-Bass)
"What America’s CEOs are reading"

"Customers.Com" is guide to using Web’s assets.
Each month, 800-CEO-READ, a division of Schwartz Business Books, compiles a list of best-selling business books based on purchases by its more than 10,000 corporate customers nationwide. Here are the Top 25 from December’s lists…

# 13.Managing a Small HRD Department
by Carol P. McCoy; Jossey-Bass

INSIGHT: Issues on HRD, ASTD - Maine Chapter, January, 1994.
Managing a Small HRD Department: You Can Do More Than You Think (Jossey-Bass)

Managing a Small HRD Department is my best friend on the job and it’s been a long time coming! I couldn’t think of a more fitting title—the book is a blessed combination of grass-root practicalities, including things like: identifying with the reader’s challenges and opportunities; the first steps of setting the stage for success; tools like sample charts, forms, evaluations and 15 worksheets ready to put to use. It’s an HRD person’s toolkit in its truest form….

The first thing that strikes me about the book is that it exudes the same warmth and personal quality that Carol projects. She easily connects with the reader, affirming the normal events, frustrations, ups and downs that small HR departments have in common. The book as a "real people" quality resulting from Carol’s descriptions of the trials, tribulations, and success stories of many people she interviewed who are in the positions of her target audience.

Carol’s target audience for the book includes virtually anyone in an HRD role: HRD and training managers, trainers, human resource generalists with responsibility for training, and those who have found themselves in a human resource development role with little or no training for it. While focused toward "small HRD departments" (one to three people), the principles are appropriate for departments of all sizes.

Carol emphasizes that the reader with limited resources needs to focus efforts on business priorities, and shows how to do so through assessment processes. She coaches the reader along in building credibility with senior management and within the organization using essential strategies of planning and communication. She helps the reader develop a resource strategy (including cost-effective delivery methods, creation of a budget, and various methods of program development) to provide excellent HRD support without the benefit of a large staff. And she talks about the importance of effective marketing and communication so that employees will know clearly what to—and what not to—expect.

Throughout the book, Carol shows a great degree of objectivity by detailing advantages and disadvantages of methods and options. She gives the reader many opportunities to learn from others’ mistakes and successes by describing her own and others’ experiences.

I can’t emphasize what a useful, practical, comprehensive and user-friendly book this is! Carol takes the reader, step-by-step, through the entire process of Human Resource Development, from creating a vision to ensuring and evaluating program effectiveness, to self- and staff-development, to addressing future challenges within organizational trends.

As much as I appreciate the entire book, the words that accompany Carol’s autograph most move me to action: "To Bobbi—Thanks for your support and encouragement. Keep the faith—you can do more than you think!" Doesn’t that go for all of us?

Bobbi Buisman, Norway Savings Bank

Training and Development, September, 1994, p. 78-79
Managing a Small HRD Department: You Can Do More Than You Think, by Carol P. McCoy. 272 pp. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass. This book can be purchased through ASTD Press, 703/683-8100.

HRD and training managers can add this terrific little spiral-bound workbook to the list of resources they’ll need to help them establish and run a small but effective human resource development department.

Carol McCoy says that more can be accomplished in a one- to three-person department than people think, but that careful planning and a constant focus on business priorities are essential to success.
In Part 1 of Managing a Small HRD Department, McCoy presents several basic strategies to use to make sure departmental efforts support the company’s goals and enhance your credibility throughout the organization. Among the strategies discussed are building partnerships, creating a business-focused HRD plan, selecting the best delivery methods for your programs and services, and developing a sound budget. With only limited resources, it is particularly important to focus your efforts on business priorities. You need to build credibility with senior management and within the organization. You must also develop and implement a resource strategy that provides HRD support without the benefit of a large staff. And you must be skillful in marketing your HRD programs and services so that employees will know clearly what you can and cannot do.
Part 2 addresses the implementation how-tos. Specifically it explains how to define departmental staff roles, market your services to managers and employees, make the most of available resources, and track program effectiveness.
Part 3 addresses management issues: for example, how to manage the training budget, how to become an effective training manager, how to develop your staff’s skills, and how to assess trends and forecast needs.
There is also a reference section that includes a detailed action plan and other reproducible worksheets that can be used to help readers plan, produce, deliver, and evaluate training activities systematically.

"Managing a small HRD department can be a tremendously challenging and rewarding experience. You may never learn more from any other assignment."

Carol McCoy is director of corporate training and development at UNUM Life Insurance Company of America and lives in Falmouth, Maine.

From Bookshelf in Brief, HRMagazine, May 1994, p. 88
Managing a Small HRD Department: You Can Do More Than You Think
This has been called a "survival guide for running a successful small HRD department."
Drawing on success stories from a variety of industries, McCoy provides a hands-on tool kit for managers of one-to-three person human resource departments that are involved in training, recruiting, compensation, employee relations and other HR functions. The book focuses on techniques for functioning effectively with limited resources and covers topics such as establishing credibility; creating a business-focused HRD plan; building, negotiating and managing a budget; managing program development and logistics; attracting customers; and ensuring and evaluating program effectiveness. Included are case studies, checklists and worksheets to help managers apply the techniques.


Back to Top




Reader's Comments about Managing a Small HRD Department
Carol Prescott McCoy (Editor), ASTD (1998). 227 pages.
James F. Orr, III, Chairman and CEO, UNUMProvident
Managing a Small HRD Department: You Can Do More Than You Think
No matter what the size of your organization, an HRD department can have a significant impact on the business by having a strategic focus and taking advantage of resources throughout the organization. This book will help anyone in HRD do this.

Jack J. Phillips, Ph.D. ~ Performance Resources Organization
I recently read your book, Managing a Small HRD Department, as a review prior to conducting a workshop on "Managing the Training Function". I found your material quite helpful and your book a great resource. On my visit to Indonesia and Malaysia, where I conducted the workshop, I recommended your book and left several copies as gifts.…I was certainly impressed with your work…

Janet Nelson, VP, Management Development ~ Chase Manhattan Bank
This book is a must-read for managers of small HRD Departments. It is filled with useful tools, examples and guidelines on how to make the best use of resources to meet the business needs of the organization. We intend to make it recommended reading for our trainers within our business units.

Charlotte S. Pollard, President ~ PO.LAR Associates, Santa Fe, New Mexico
Carol McCoy is one of the most resourceful people I know. She has a knack for putting together the talent, funds, and technology to make things happen for any problem or opportunity she encounters. It is not surprising that she has done the same with this book. You will find a wealth of ideas, examples, and recommendations for how to handle many of the issues common to small HRD departments. After reading this book, you will find yourself looking at these issues with optimism. This book will prepare you for a "can do" attitude when you encounter obstacles that once seemed insurmountable.
Clayton W. Churchill, Northeast Management: Business in the 90’s
I have your book (Managing a Small HRD Department) in my briefcase and have been reviewing it while I travel. You have done a great job at organizing and presenting each topic. The book is a good resource for any HR leader looking for new ideas and a fresh perspective.
Jack P. Lerner, Director, Management Development and Training ~ C. R. Bard, Inc.
This is the closest thing to an operating manual as you’ll find in the field. I read it right before taking a start-up, one-person HRD position. It’s kept me focused and productive; I still haven’t removed all the post-it notes.
Marie T. Eiter, PH.D. Director of Executive Education ~ The Amos Tuck School of Business, Dartmouth College
This book should be required reading for all managers of training and development. Dr. McCoy has done an excellent job in synthesizing what we know about creating and managing a small HRD department. Written as a guide to assist managers of small HRD departments within large decentralized organizations, as well as HRD departments in smaller firms, this book fills a void in the professional literature. It provides managers with a well organized and clear reference for choosing options in delivering HRD, projecting a training budget, and project planning for program development.
Sharon Korth, Executive Human Resource Development Graduate Program ~ Xavier University, Cincinnati, OH

I teach a course on Managing Human Resource Development Programs which is the capstone course in the Executive HRD Masters Degree Program at Xavier University. We have used your text (Managing a Small HRD Department) for two cohort groups and I am following up to let you know the students’ reactions to the text. In general, they regarded the text very highly. They liked the ongoing case examples, loved the worksheets, and thought the flow was logical. They thought it was clearly written and will serve as a resource and reference for them in the future. One student had just moved into a position as HRD manager and used the framework to begin her job.
Overall, the students liked the text and we plan to use it in the upcoming course….Thanks for the opportunity for the direct feedback.


Back to Top


Reader's Comments about In Action: Managing the Small Training Staff
Carol Prescott McCoy (Editor), ASTD (1998). 227 pages.
Lisa Napolitano, PHR, Training Coordinator ~ DELORME
Thank you for yet another outstanding HRD resource! I am thoroughly enjoying your newest book, "Managing a Small Training Staff." Much like "Managing a Small HRD Department," I have found this book tremendously useful and practical. These are two must-have resources for anyone new to human resource development or in a small HRD department.
For me, what sets these two books apart from the rest is the combination of step by step guidelines with real-world examples which you support with wonderful insights into adult learning theory and explanations of the potential challenges and hidden opportunities one may encounter along the way. In fact, the case studies and worksheets you provide make it feel like I have a " personal coach" and a network of HRD professionals at my fingertips!
Once again Carol, many thanks for your insight and guidance. Your books and continuing education courses are a clear demonstration of your dedication to helping HRD professionals do more with less. I look forward to working with you again soon.
Sue Dubuque, Dubuque Consulting
From Amazon.com, September 3, 1999
As a training consultant I often get tapped by organizations to help design, refine and implement small HRD departments. The training function is often the last HR specialty to be added and one in which HR generalists have the least experience. Managing the Small Training Staff offers the reader a wide variety of initiatives and interventions for the reader to review. I have utilized this book in my consulting practice to expose new practitioners to a variety of real life training experiences. I particularly appreciate the candor of the writers who elaborate on both successful and unsuccessful efforts. A great case study book for new trainers and a valuable resource for more seasoned practitioners.
Mary Collins, University of Southern Maine
From Amazon.com, March 24, 1999
I have reviewed this book from the perspective of an instructor teaching graduate level HRD classes. Students in my classes range from aspiring professionals who have no prior HRD experience to those with significant experience. It is always a dilemma to find texts that can meet the needs of all the students; but I think this one can. For the inexperienced student, the 12 cases provide a solid base of information about what the training role is all about, at least in small training departments. For experienced practitioners, it provides examples of how other professionals have addressed opportunities and challenges common to everyone in similar roles. While it does not profess to be a compendium of best practices, it certainly can be used to benchmark one’s own practices.
The twelve cases cover businesses of various sizes and in various industries from a small rural bank to a large multi-national bio-medical manufacturing company. In none of the cases were there more than 5 training staff. The cases are presented using a somewhat standard format: a description of the company, a description of training’s mission, role and structure, discussion of some challenges, a success story and some lessons learned…

Back to Top